Showing posts with label monetization. Show all posts
Showing posts with label monetization. Show all posts

Monday, November 17, 2008

Monetization: How Much Can I Make From Advertising With My Facebook App?

Another question I get from developers all the time: how much money can I make on Facebook?

Shocking, I know that some people care about money when it comes to Facebook apps. <cynicism>Wait...I think that's all most developers care about. </cynicism>

At the moment, there's only one publicly traded app developer, SNAP Interactive. <cynicism>Keep your fingers Max Levchin (Slide), it'll happen for you too one day, I'm sure of it!</cynicism>

Fortunately for us, SNAP Interactive has to publish their revenues, which currently comes exclusively from advertising on the dating apps on Facebook. Those apps: Are You Interested? (#1 dating app on Facebook), Meet New People, and Flirt With Me.

Here's the numbers from the SEC filing:

Revenue increased from $286 for the six months ended June 30, 2007 to $1,053,159 for the six months ended June 30, 2008, an increase of $1,052,873.
That's right, zero to a million in revenue in one year. Not bad. Especially, if you look at the expense side.
Operating Expenses for the six months ended June 30, 2008 increased to $717,349 from $277,634 for the six months ended June 30, 2007, representing an increase of $439,715.
That's ~$300,000 in profit. A 30% profit margin. And it looks like that doesn't include the founder's salary. Nice.

Hosting costs, <cynicism>for all you STILL writing business plans...poor bastards</cynicism>are as follows:
Hosting Expense for the six months ended June 30, 2008 increased to $87,512 from $0, representing an increase of $87,512. These increases are attributable to the need for substantial hosting infrastructure and server capacity to handle the high volume of traffic that our applications receive. Our need for a customized hosting solution was minimal at this time last year.
Read the rest of their filing here. Trust me, if you haven't learned to enjoy reading SEC filings yet, you will.

By the way, SNAP Interactive's money comes from ad revenue. The real money is in virtual goods.

Wednesday, October 15, 2008

CPA Offers: A Safe Harbor in an Advertising Recession?

Many, if not most, of the successful social games are using CPA offers tied to in-game virtual currency to monetize, in addition to advertising.

However, while advertising spending is expected to slow in a recession, particularly brand advertising, performance-based CPA offers are expected to do well.

Or STRENGTHEN. According to a good friend of mine who works for a company that provides the CPA offer inventory to companies such as SuperRewards and Offerpal, the last two months have been his company's BEST EVER.

That bodes well for social games companies. We have a core revenue stream that not only will survive a recession, but possibly improve. Awesome.

However, there is a flipside. Daniel James, CEO of Three Rings (maker of social gaming worlds, Puzzle Pirates and Whirled) mentioned in his presentation that his cost per acquisition using CPA offers had dropped over the last few months as he experimented with different advertising techniques. He could buy the same amount of CPA traffic for half the price, which he attributed to a softness in the ad market.

So a provider of CPA offers sees his best months ever and a buyer of CPA offers is seeing cheaper inventory. One possible explanation: increased volume of CPA inventory so that even as the price of CPA drops, the amount makes up for it.

Other explanation welcome in the comments.

Monday, August 18, 2008

Will Facebook Users Pay to Play? CasualCafe Thinks So.

You might be surprised to find out that my favorite game on Facebook is Spyde Solitaire. When I was a depressed college student, sucking down coke (the cola) and listening to old Smiths songs, I spent hours playing Spider Solitaire. Yes, I was emo, so kill me.

CasualCafe's Spyde Solitaire takes the Puzzle Quest model of applying a quest structure to a simple casual game (Match 3) and brings it to Spider Solitaire. It's has extremely good production values and well-thought out game design. It's very compelling.

So compelling that some people are willing to pay for the experience. In fact, they have to be, CasualCafe requires users to buy credits to play. Currently, they charge 1 credit for 10 minutes of play.

Here's their pricing tier:


So about a penny per minute at the $25 option, which according to founder Michael Scholz is much more popular than he expected (though he won't say how popular).

Scholz says he believes that once the dust settles, about 1-2% of players will pay for the experience. As all you old hands out there know, 1-2% is the conversion rate in the downloadable casual space. There's a lot of evidence that the same demographic (women 35+) are some of the most addicted game players of Facebook (I believe that at Interplay, Josh Williams of Alamofire indicated that Packrat's most rabid players are in this demographic). It's also one of the fastest growing demographic segments of Facebook.

Geographic breakdown also surprised Scholz. "I am also surprised by our uptake in Australia and UK, we're lucky we happened to have a paypal payment path that could support those players, because we weren't anticipating early adoption over there."

Right now, CasualCafe only has about 10,000 monthly users. I'm surprised it's that high. Asking Facebook users to pay for something is a hard sell when every other game is free. But of course, as many free to play developers have said to me, it's only a very small slice of players that make a game profitable like 1-2%, in fact. The rest of us are cheap bastards. :)

Hopefully, Michael will release more data once he has it. CasualCafe's experience will be very instructive for the rest of us.

CasualCafe is self-funded for now. Michael was Director of Technology at SkillJam, a skill-based casual games portal, before it was acquired for $200 million. Guess he had some stock.

Monday, August 4, 2008

A Primer on Monetizing Social Games

My friend Peter Vogel, senior marketing at Memolink/CPA Storm recently (as is last month) wrote a very good summary of the techniques that social games are using to monetize. It even has some numbers. Mostly notably, is the claim that there's a few social game developers making over a million bucks a year. It's true. In the social games industry, it's an open secret. Some companies, Like Zynga, are making 1 million dollars a month, according to Roman Nouzareth, CEO of Boonty/Cafe.com who heard it from a little birdie and is not an official number provided by Zynga (a statement he made during our panel discussion at Casual Connect - you should have been there).

Here's a snippet to whet your appetite.

Much more potent, though, is to use CPA offers to monetize an app’s virtual currency. This is the most inherently social of all of the models. Many apps have a virtual economies where users can earn and spend points (or other virtual currency). Users trade in the “points” to send a virtual piece of sushi to friend or “buy” a pink tutu for their virtual elephant on (fluff)Friends. Sometimes they just want to have the most “points” of all their friends. Developers have long used virtual economies to motivate users to perform viral actions like inviting friends to install the app, but CPA offers give users a chance to earn extra virtual currency. Users might complete a short survey, fill out a lead form, or even sign up for a service like Netflix. In exchange for completing an offer, they earn more of app’s virtual currency. Often times these interactions are real-time, so users can earn the virtual currency immediately, without even having to leave the app.